Well, what do you know. I’ve discovered this vermouth cocktail just in time—by which I mean, the exact chapter of life where my tolerance has plummeted and my taste has gotten smug.
There’s a sad poetry to it. As I’ve aged, my palate has become more refined (less juice, more nuance), while my body has grown tragically less interested in metabolizing alcohol. These days, anything over three drinks and I’m saying goodnight early, laying out Motrin like a little bedside mint.
I no longer drink to get drunk. Or even “tipsy.” Drinking games? Please. I’ve reached the dignified age where sacrificing those activities doesn’t feel like a loss—it feels like dodging a misdemeanor.
That said, my drink preferences are now wildly unsuited to anything with the word “game” in it. Can you imagine playing “Quarters” with a Negroni? I’d be found horizontal somewhere between round two and liver failure. And if I had to take a shot of Manhattan every time someone said “Never have I ever…” I’d be telling my stories to an ICU nurse.
So now that I can only responsibly have one (maybe two) cocktails, I’ve become insufferably picky. They have to count. No syrupy mixers, no melted ice piles, no drinks that taste like the bar ran out of ideas and dumped in a can of Sprite. And vodka? You better have a notarized reason for including that.
A perfect cocktail has to show up like it knows what it’s doing—something with structure. A spirit, a liqueur, acid, a touch of sweetness, and most important: bitter backbone. Which brings us, reverently, to vermouth.
Specifically Carpano Antica.
This stuff is not the sad bottle of Martini & Rossi abandoned in the back of your parents’ cabinet. Carpano Antica is the kind of vermouth that ruins you for the others. It’s dark and herbal, with notes of fig, licorice, cocoa, and some mythical Italian forest where monks drink cocktails before dinner. Somehow rich and dry at the same time, and not the slightest bit syrupy. I keep a bottle in the fridge and eye it like a prized truffle.
Yes, it’s glorious on its own. But mix it into a proper Manhattan or a real Negroni, and suddenly you realize: it was never the gin or the whiskey. It was always the vermouth.
Lately, I’ve been enjoying it in a classic vermouth cocktail—equal parts charm and restraint. As an aperitif, it gently nudges your appetite instead of flattening it. It satisfies the grown-up palate without launching me straight into post-dinner regret. Two is fine. Three is pushing it. Four is when the housekeeper finds you curled around a throw pillow muttering about Campari.
But one or two? Heaven. Complex, bitter, and elegant.
Just like me.
Vermouth Cocktail
This is what you will need:
- 2 oz. premium sweet vermouth. Please try for Carpano Antica these days.
- 1/4 teaspoon kirsch or Grand Marnier
- 2 dashes Payschaud's Bitters
- Lemon peel for garnish (not optional)
This is how you make it:
- Combine ingredients in a mixing glass. Stir well until chilled, about 45 seconds. Strain into chilled cocktail glass. Twist lemon peel over drink and use as garnish.




















Yes, each beverage needs to count.
Bourbon is my base of choice these days – I usually save the rum for making vanilla extract.
I think I would take my age & my more discriminating tastes over my youth and my very indiscriminate choices any day. (Not that I have a choice…)
Bourbon is my drink of choice as well. For medicinal purposes only, of course.
LOL at your “Quarters” mention…my youngest sister (and her cohorts) put tons of dings in our family dining room table when my parents left her home alone one weekend. Those were the days. Gorgeous drink and I’ll have to spring for some premium vermouth.
Did those dings end up becoming a cherished part of the table? If our tables could talk…wow.
Kindred spirits, so to speak. I too find that every drop must count. It’s an age thing I guess. Long gone are the all nighters, and the dreadful chug a lug. But that is alright. Youth, as they say, is wasted on the young. The older I get the more of a real appreciation I have developed for fine spirits.
What a classic you have presented. I enjoyed reading your comments about Carpano, or what a dear friend (and cocktail lover) calls “my beloved Carpano.” A fine vermouth indeed. I am a Cocchi fan, but far be it from me to deny a man his vermouth of choice.
I must comment on your extraordinarily evocative photographs. They remind me of having a drink in the gorgeous bar of the Four Seasons Clift in San Francisco – all dark, woody and old school. Very old school. Thank you, Trevor.
Ah, “Kindred Spirits” sounds like a lovely drink name doesn’t it? I will keep some Cocchi on deck for next time but I too consider the Carpano ‘beloved’. I just opened a Cocchi Americano and I’m casting about for ways to enjoy it. Any ideas?
I’m in love with those glasses and the lemon ribbon.
Thank you Angela! They are some glasses I haven’t broken out to use in a VERY long time.
This looks perfect for a Thursday cocktail!
Any day is a great day for a Thursday cocktail IMHO!
Love love your photos, and those glasses are sexy old school! Now in my 30’s, I’ve discovered a love for the crafted cocktail instead of all the sugary “just 21” drinks!
Cheers~
Tiffany @thymeoftaste
Truth be told I have a bit of a hangover right now but it is a testament to your lovely photos that this post actually makes me want a drink despite that. Really, truly.
Gorgeous photos, Trevor. You’ll have to fill me in on the shoot.
There is no other way to make a proper Negroni – you have to use Carpano. Looks like you have joined the Carpano Snobs Anonymous Society!
I prefer to think of it as ‘high expectations’ rather than snobbery! But yes, there is always a bottle of it in my fridge ready for a Negroni and, of course, this vermouth cocktail.